ladyofastolat: (sneezing lion)
ladyofastolat ([personal profile] ladyofastolat) wrote2016-07-10 01:33 pm

Legless in Yore

Today I have mostly been ranting about the way that trousers (for which read trousers or hose or braies or braccae or leg wrappings or any other leg covering of choice) have been airbrushed out of Yore and Fantasyland. It is well-known that people don't wear socks in Fantasyland, even though they jolly well should. In a recent episode of Game of Thrones, SPOILER, recently returned from an absence of a considerable number of episodes, killed someone, took his boots, and put them on over entirely bare feet. I had to try a few million pairs of boots on before I found some that were comfortable for long walks, and even then, I wear two pairs of socks. I warned SPOILER about blisters. He didn't listen.

But trousers (hose, braies, breeches, whatever) appear to have been excised, too. I've been reading a very silly vaguely Arthurian novel in which a feisty warrior woman goes round wearing a jerkin over entirely bare legs. Now, the internet offers up a dazzling array of images of jerkin, but none of them would be remotely decent when worn over bare legs. I've also been watching Arthur of the Britons, in which the costume department clearly added an accidental few extra noughts to their order of white sheepskins, and, forced to cover up their mistake, have shrouded every single Saxon extra in at least four sheep. Some are positively spherical in their sheepskin cardigans, some of whom wear them over bare, spindly little legs, with bare, spindly little arms and shoulders struggling to emerge from the white globe of sheep.*

These are the two examples that have troubled me today, but it is an ongoing rant, prompted by numerous historic and fantasy films, and by the sight of chilly Roman re-enactors shivering bare-legged in the British cold.

Personally, I never wear shorts on a walk, because walks often involve wading through brambles and bracken and other scratchy things, and I want the protection of a layer of fabric, thank you very much. It would tend to ruin the impact of a surprise ambush if all your bare-leggety warriors were constantly going "ow! ooh!" as they knelt in thistles and squelched in slimy cow pats. Warriors who charge naked into battle, clad only in woad and bravado, are presumably hard enough to cope with the string and prickles of outrageous flora, but why would those who've bothered to clothe their top half forget to bother with clothing anything under the waist?

*

In Arthur of the Briton, they also make their saddle cloths out of Bagpuss.

bagpuss

[identity profile] siglinde99.livejournal.com 2016-07-11 01:48 am (UTC)(link)
This amused me greatly. A longer tunic (at least knee length, but not dragging on the ground) makes a lot of sense with a pair of socks and shoes. It's easy for personal hygiene (dropping pants to go to the bathroom in the cold weather is quite chilly - even with undergarmentry, there is some protection from the wind). Long is okay for wealthy nobles might be okay to show off (hand spun and woven fabric is valuable, so allowing it to get dirty or torn is like burning money). Short tunics and bare legs? No way - especially when riding a horse! Pants were one of the ways barbarians were distinguished from Romans. They rode horses a lot, as well as living in more northerly regions.

The image of floofy Saxons made me laugh.

Coincidentally, friends and I were discussing a related issue just today. One trained as a lawyer, and got completely turned off a TV show because of a blatant error related to copyright law. The archivist nearly lost it over another show that talked about zero relative humidity in the Vatican library (which would have turned every document to dust).
Edited 2016-07-11 01:49 (UTC)

[identity profile] ladyofastolat.livejournal.com 2016-07-11 11:29 am (UTC)(link)
The Romans had Opinions on trousers, but the Vindolanda tablets show that people on Hadrian's Wall, at least, wore socks. Not that you'd believe that socks existed from the costume of most Roman re-enactors.

Having struggled with going to the toilet while wearing a shift and a floor-length medieval-style dress on a VERY wet day, I can say from experience that this, too, is very chilly. Having six inches of sodden hem brushing against your bare bottom on a freezing cold day is not at all nice!

I always get particularly bothered with breaches of Data Protection rules in movies - e.g. when a character walks into some institution and, merely by asking, is given the full contact details of one of their customers.